INCOMPLETE WORK IN PROGRESS - please contact: john@newschool futures
Exceptions
(see rigour, element, heart and other keywords)
Exceptions sometimes trump rules
- Alfred Jarry coined the term Pataphysics around 1893.
- While some regard it as a parody of science, others see it as a branch of philosophy or science.
- As such, it would explore imaginary phenomena, in a conjectural way, perhaps by conceiving a world that transcends metaphysical constraints.
- Learners can find opportunities by finding imaginary solutions based on exceptions rather than rules.
Our industrial past
- Evolution works differently from the way that industries work.
- Whereas industry learned to set standards and rules, evolution depends on difference and diversity.
- Without some deviation from the prevailing paradigm, new forms of life would not be possible.
- However, the last 10K years of human history taught us to find methods and to apply them systematically.
- This now also applies to methodologies of innovation.
- Humans have created a monetary system designed to make each dollar seem identical to every other dollar.
- By contrast, every living system (e.g. human learner) is unique and autopoietic
- Evolution in the living world therefore depends on exceptions, rather than rules and standards.
The University Paradigm
- Fortunately, many of the above habits and preoccupations linger on in today's universities.
- Their practices became ossified by common bureaucratic procedures that - at worst - value the fairness of grading above the joy of learning.
- We can apply the best of both traditions by widening the scope of learning and by giving learners a greater level of creative autonomy.
- The deep purpose of learning is often overshadowed by bureaucratic reasoning that turns complex experiences and values into quantities.
- Over the last few centuries the culture of books was challenged by a series of technological innovations.
- e.g. the printing press, then digital storage, voice recognition, multi-media and, more recently, AI systems.
The Art School Paradigm
- One way to augment the 'Head-based' approach is to add a touch of art school thinking.
- Although today's art schools emulated the mainstream universities, they have a mediaeval Crafts Guilds (i.e. not a monastic) heritage.
- Here, arguably, the idea of 'knowing' is less definable as a truth-claim and more as knowing how - i.e. as an outcome-oriented process of shaping to make things work.
- Although art schools are now assimilated into a common university framework this did little to change the University Paradigm.
- Universities set 'standards' in order to uphold academic rigour.