Loading...
 

Artificial Intelligence (AI)

One White Bit (Also see beyond assessment, tacit knowledge, wisdom, knowledge, shamanism & other keywords)

One White Bit a provisional definition...

    • A system designed to emulate (the outward appearance of) human learning & problem-solving.

One White Bit Noun Writing 2501252

The big picture

  • Our species faces climatic, military and ecological threats to the livability of planet Earth.  
  • It would be reasonable to expect universities to re-design themselves for their deep, long term purpose.

One White Bit This context

  • This page offers a commentary on trends within the education system.
  • It is not intended to offer a comprehensive exploration of AI's potential in fields, such as:
    • medicine, software coding or healthcare.
    • virtual assistants like Siri and Alexa.
    • personalized online content recommendations.
    • fraud detection systems in banking.
    • navigation apps using real-time traffic data.
  • On the other hand, we know our global supply chains depend heavily on digital, electronic networks and technologies that are prone to attack and failure.
  • Societal resilience will diminish if our systems of learning fail to think beyond our technological dependency.

A pedagogic arms race?

One White Bit Noun Cyborg 5265026 Noun Cyborg 5265026 Noun Cyborg 5265026 One White Bit Noun Cyborg 2523829
One White Bit ChatGPT versus Gradescope

  • Currently, our education system reflects the short-termism of current economic and political orthodoxies.
  • Many universities appear to expect undetectable plagiarism as a fact of life 
  • This has led to an AI arms race between teachers and learners.

How AI is being adopted in the UK

  1. The Russell Group of Universities has approved some uses of AI (see comment) despite the fact that it encourages plagiarism.
    • e.g. Anglia Ruskin University uses AI-Assisted Grading and Feedback and claim a 40% increase in what they call "grading efficiency"
  2. The University of Suffolk offers AI adaptive learning systems for tailoring course material for individual learners.
  3. The Open University uses AI to identify students who do not fulfil their expectation (they also claim this gives them a 40% improvement for academic achievement).
  4. The University of Brighton uses Snippet-Based AI Learning to boost student learning retention by 38%.
  5. The University of Hertfordshire uses AI in analysing skill gaps and personalizing learning strategies - they claim a 35% improvement in overall academic performance.
  6. Buckinghamshire New University uses AI and claims that it has reduced plagiarism by 45%

Can AI support Real Intelligence

  • How useful is it to spare learners the task of looking for answers to questions that are unique to themselves?
  • Many applications are sophisticated augmentations of digital search techniques.
  • They obviate the otherwise troublesome routines of looking for known answers to verbally posed questions.
    • (n.b. the Self Evaluating Learning Framework was designed to obviate plagiarism (Wood, 1992 & 2005)
    • See my IDEAbase system (Taylor & Wood, 1997) that sought to enhance the creative agency of the user, rather than to offer the more mechanical (and parasitic) search faculties.

Limitations of AI in learning

  • Some research shows that handwriting aids some learning when compared with keyboard usage.
  • AI systems tend to offer answers that were previously deemed by humans to be useful, correct, optimal or average.
    • This often means they may replicate the social or psychological biases of those used to train them.
  • An important aspect of AI's 'artificiality' is its allopoietic nature.
    • The autopoietic nature of living systems mean they have no purpose, apart from surviving.
    • In this regard, AI systems use algorithms to fulfil a specific pre-ordained purpose.
One White Bit Disembodied Intelligence
  • Digital computer systems have no wetware (e.g. self-coordinating metabolic processes such as the endocrine system).
  • They are based on written codes that apply rules and meta-rules.
  • By contrast, humans not only think with their minds but, also, with their bodies.
One White Bit Codes and Algorithms
One White Bit Voices from the Dead
  • Plato criticised alphabetical writing for seeming intelligent but repeating itself when challenged.
  • AI also depends on information or knowledge largely gleaned from the past.
  • Of course, computer-based writing can make texts appear to adapt to a new context.
  • Nonetheless, it is the same illusion but applied at an organisational level.
    • e.g. The Turing Test is often cited to celebrate how good we are at simulating a living presence.
    • However, this may mask the strong human tendency to anthropomorphise non-living things.
    • e.g. Weizenbaum's Doctor program was based on the radically patient-centred dialogues of Carl Rogers (we are easily fooled).

Further reading

  • Taylor, P., & Wood, J., (1997), Mapping the Mapper, a chapter in "Computers, Communications, and Mental Models", eds. Donald Day & Diane Kovacs, Taylor & Francis, London, ISBN 0-7484-0543-7, pp. 37-44, January 1997.
  • Wood, J., (2005) “The Tetrahedron Can Encourage Designers To Formalise More Responsible Strategies”, for the "Journal of Art, Design & Communication", Volume 3 Issue 3, Editor, Linda Drew, UK, ISSN: 1474-273X, pp. 175-192
  • Wood, J., (1992), "The Notion of Relational Design"; a paper given at the 17th ICSID Conference - Ljubljana, Slovenia, 1992 May.
  • ChatGPT is Dumber Than You Think